Notes

Publishers Want Wishlists Before They Fund. Your Press Starts Before the Deal.

For a long time, the order of operations for a smaller studio was simple. Find a publisher, get funded, build the game, and let the publisher's marketing team worry about who had heard of it. Press was something that happened near the end.

According to the people who sign the checks, that order has flipped.

What happened

Last week the organizers of the GDC Festival of Gaming released their State of the Game Industry report. Most of the headlines went to layoffs, and for good reason. The report says 34% of respondents were laid off in the past two years, and 54% of those laid off are still unemployed.

The line that matters most for anyone pitching a game came in an interview. Survey lead Beth Elderkin told GamesIndustry.biz that "publishers are expecting more right out of the gate." In her words: "They want your game to have a high number of wishlists and a social media following, and they want it to be in a very good state."

She also named the trap. "You have to get something good enough to present, but you need funding to do that." The report says half of studio workers now count self-funding as their primary source of money, with publishing deals or project-based funding at 15%.

Visibility is now part of the term sheet

Put those findings together and the implication is plain. If a publisher wants proof of demand before it invests, then the public story of a game is now part of the funding pitch. It isn't something you hand off once the deal is done.

The same week showed what that looks like. PC Gamer reported that "approximately 20" developers laid off from id Software in Microsoft's July Xbox cuts have formed Hidden Horses, an employee-owned studio planning a Kickstarter for its first game. One co-founder said they wanted to "invite those players along for the journey from the very beginning." And Black Forest Games bought itself out of Embracer, launching a new studio group with the line that "some of the best games of the last decade came from teams of fifty, not five hundred."

Both are good stories. Both also show the new reality. A studio's first announcement is now its first piece of evidence, read by players, press and potential partners at the same time.

Where studios get this wrong

These are patterns we see across the category, not a read on any studio named here.

Treating the studio announcement as the whole story. "Veterans of a famous studio go independent" gets one news cycle. After that, reporters and players want to know about the game. If the next thing you have to say is months away, the following you earned on day one tends to drift.

Confusing reach with demand. A viral clip isn't the same thing as people who want to buy the game, and publishers know the difference. Attention that doesn't connect to the game itself looks good in a deck right up until someone asks about it.

Leaning on the layoff. Coming out of a cut is real context, and audiences can be generous about it. But the story is the team and the work, not the grievance. Pitches that read as a reaction to a former employer age badly, and they can cause trouble with people you may want to work with again.

Saying one thing to publishers and another to players. The ambitious version of the game in the funding deck and the modest version in the trailer will eventually meet in the same article. Scope, platforms and timing should sound the same everywhere.

Going quiet on the questions you know are coming. The same report says 55% of respondents think generative AI is hurting the industry. If AI touches your pipeline, players and press will ask. Deciding how you talk about it before the announcement is much easier than deciding mid-thread.

Overpromising dates to look fundable. A dated reveal makes a pitch feel concrete. A missed date then becomes the headline, and the publisher you were courting sees it too.

Why it matters now

The calendar is crowded. Holiday releases are taking up attention now, and the run-up to awards season and early-year showcases soon follows. Studios that want to walk into publisher meetings next year with a real following are, in practice, deciding this quarter what their public story is.

None of this means every studio needs a big launch campaign before it has a playable build. Often the right move is smaller. That might be one clear story about the team and the game, told consistently, to the outlets and communities that actually cover that kind of game. What's changed is that this early work is no longer optional. It's what the funding conversation is built on.

Publishers want to see that people are paying attention. The studios that get funded will be the ones that gave them a reason to.

Building a game and pitching publishers next year? Request a briefing.